Raising Stoics
Study brief · Praise and growth mindset

Growth mindset research: what holds up about praise

The short version: Growth mindset research shows that how you praise does shape how children handle failure — praise for being smart made children avoid challenges. But the big claims for growth-mindset programs are much weaker than their reputation: on average, their effect on achievement is tiny.

Help your child handle big feelings. A 12-week program for kids 5–6: 20 minutes, twice a week.
See the program

The studies

Mueller, C. M., & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33–52. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.75.1.33

Who was studied: Fifth graders (ages 10–12) across six experiments.

Design: Laboratory experiments

What they found: Children praised for being smart after an easy task were more likely to choose easy problems next, enjoyed the task less, persisted less after a failure, and did worse afterward — compared with children praised for their effort. In one experiment, some misreported their scores to other children.

Sisk, V. F., Burgoyne, A. P., Sun, J., Butler, J. L., & Macnamara, B. N. (2018). To what extent and under which circumstances are growth mind-sets important to academic achievement? Two meta-analyses. Psychological Science, 29(4), 549–571. doi:10.1177/0956797617739704

Who was studied: 273 studies with about 366,000 students, and 43 intervention studies with about 57,000 students.

Design: Two meta-analyses

What they found: The link between having a growth mindset and doing well in school was weak, and programs that teach growth mindset had, on average, only small effects on achievement. Students from low-income families or those at academic risk may benefit somewhat more.

How strong is the evidence?

The praise finding is a classic but was done with older children, and some later studies (for example, Li and Bates, 2019, with Chinese schoolchildren) did not find the same effects. The meta-analyses are strong evidence that growth-mindset programs are not the powerful fix they were sold as.

What these studies don't show

  • They don't show that 5-year-olds respond the same way as 10-year-olds — the classic study didn't test young children.
  • They don't show that saying "yet" or praising effort improves grades. It's a small nudge, not a program.

What it means for parents

  • Describe what your child did rather than who they are: "You tried it three different ways" instead of "You're so smart."
  • Keep expectations realistic. A single phrase won't transform a child — the everyday reaction to mistakes, repeated over time, is what counts.
  • Model it: make a mistake out loud and try another way.

What growth mindset research actually tested

The idea behind growth mindset comes from psychologist Carol Dweck's work on what people believe about ability. Some people see intelligence as fixed — you have a certain amount and that's that. Others see it as something that grows with effort and good strategies. Dweck called these a fixed and a growth mindset.

The best-known study for parents is Mueller and Dweck's 1998 series of experiments with children ages 10–12. Children solved a set of puzzles and were then praised in one of three ways: for being smart, for working hard, or for the score alone. They were then given a much harder set and told they had done much worse.

Children praised for intelligence afterward preferred easy tasks that would make them look good, enjoyed the puzzles less after failing, and some misreported their scores to others. Children praised for effort preferred challenging tasks that would teach them something and kept their enjoyment after failure.

The theory that followed was that the way adults talk about ability shapes children's beliefs, and those beliefs shape how they respond to difficulty. It's a plausible and useful idea — which is exactly why it spread so quickly, often faster than the evidence.

Why the big claims shrank

In the 2010s, growth mindset became a school program, a poster, and a slogan. Larger studies then checked how much difference it really made.

Two meta-analyses published together in 2018 by Sisk and colleagues pulled together hundreds of studies. They found that students' mindsets had only a weak relationship with their grades, and that mindset programs had, on average, a very small effect on academic achievement. The effects were somewhat larger for students from low-income families and for those who were struggling most.

The largest single test, the National Study of Learning Mindsets, published in Nature in 2019, gave a short online growth-mindset program to thousands of US ninth graders. Lower-achieving students saw a small improvement in grades — around a tenth of a grade point — and more students overall enrolled in advanced math courses. The grade effect was larger in schools where peers supported the message. Higher-achieving students saw little change.

So the research doesn't say growth mindset is nonsense. It says the effect of teaching it is real but small, varies by child and setting, and is far from a single idea changing a child's life. Almost none of this research involves children as young as five.

What praise research says about young children

Some of the most interesting studies for parents of 4- to 7-year-olds are about praise itself, not mindset programs.

In a 2007 study, Andrei Cimpian and colleagues found that small differences in wording mattered even for 4-year-olds. Children told "you are a good drawer" — praise about the person — reacted worse to later mistakes than children told "you did a good job drawing" — praise about the action. The first group was more likely to criticize themselves and to persist less after a mistake.

A long-term study by Elizabeth Gunderson and colleagues, published in 2013, recorded how parents praised their children at home between the ages of one and three. The more of their praise was about process — effort, strategies, actions — the more likely the children were, years later at seven and eight, to believe that abilities can be improved and to prefer challenges.

These studies are smaller than the school trials and show links rather than guaranteed effects. But they point in a practical direction: for young children, the habit of describing what a child did, rather than labeling who they are, is worth building.

Process praise at home: what it sounds like

Process praise describes something the child did, so they know what to repeat. A few examples for everyday moments:

Instead of "You're so smart" after a finished puzzle: "You tried lots of pieces in that corner until one fit." Instead of "You're a great artist": "You used so many colors in the sky. Tell me about it." Instead of "Good girl" after cleaning up: "You put every car back in the box." Instead of "You're a natural" after riding a bike: "You kept practicing even when you wobbled."

Keep it honest. Praising effort when a child hasn't tried, or when the effort isn't working, can backfire. If they're stuck, praise the attempt and help with the strategy: "You've worked hard on this. Let's try a different way." Dweck herself has warned against a "false growth mindset" that praises effort alone without helping children find better approaches.

And don't overdo it. Some researchers argue that constant praise, of any kind, can make children depend on adult approval. Sometimes the best response is simply interest: "How did you do that?"

What parents can take from growth mindset research

Put together, the research supports a few modest, practical habits rather than a program.

Describe the process more than the person. It's the part of the field with the most direct evidence for young children, and it costs nothing.

Treat mistakes as normal, out loud. Children read adults' reactions to failure — including adults' own failures — and draw conclusions about what mistakes mean.

Pair effort with strategy. "Try harder" isn't enough when a child is stuck. "Let's try a different way" teaches that improvement comes from changing approach, not only from pushing.

Offer challenges that are just a little too hard. A child who only ever does easy things never gets to find out that struggle leads somewhere.

And keep expectations realistic. None of this will transform a child's grades or personality on its own. What it can do is make failure a little less frightening and trying again a little more likely — which, at ages 4–7, is a skill worth building.

FAQ

How do students with a growth mindset see their mistakes?

As information about what to change, not as proof they aren't good at something. A child with a growth mindset is more likely to think "that way didn't work — I'll try another" and to go back to a task they failed at. Research links these beliefs to more persistence after failure, although the effect on school results is modest.

Why is growth mindset important?

Because beliefs about ability affect how children respond to difficulty: whether they try again or give up. Research supports that link, especially for how children react to failure. But the effect of growth-mindset programs on grades is small on average, so it's best seen as one helpful ingredient — alongside good teaching, practice, and support — not a cure-all.

Has growth mindset been debunked?

No, but it's been scaled down. Large studies and meta-analyses find that mindset has only a weak link with achievement and that programs have small average effects, larger for struggling students. The core idea — that how children think about ability shapes how they handle challenge — holds up. The bold claims about transforming results don't.

How should I praise my child?

Describe what they did, specifically: the effort, the strategy, the persistence, the choices. "You kept going when it got hard" teaches more than "you're so smart." Be honest — don't praise effort that wasn't there — and don't praise constantly. Curiosity ("How did you work that out?") is often better than any praise.

Is it bad to tell my child they're smart?

Once in a while, no harm is done. The issue is a steady diet of praise for fixed traits — smart, talented, a natural — which research suggests can make children more cautious about challenges and more upset by failure. Describing what they did gives the same warmth without the side effects.

What is a fixed mindset in a child?

A fixed mindset is the belief that ability is set — you're either good at something or you aren't. In a young child it often shows up as avoiding hard tasks, giving up quickly, saying "I'm bad at this" after one mistake, or getting very upset when something doesn't work the first time. Many children show it in some areas and not others.

Not Yet (lesson 17) and Plan B (lesson 20) practice what to do after something goes wrong — the part of growth mindset that holds up best.

See the program

Next article

What Is a Growth Mindset? Growth Mindset for Kids, Explained

What is a growth mindset, and how do you teach it to a 4- to 7-year-old? Why praising kids for being smart backfires, and the sentences that work instead.

Read next →